Tuesday, February 18, 2014

A FUDGET - come in to my parlour-said the spider, opening his fly


SUSPENDED ANIMATION A 'fudget' was presented. Ripley's "Believe It Or Not" series seems tame compared to this. A freebie to the rogue automotive industry. A false impression that the fiscal is on the path to recovery- by suppressing expenditure and inflating income.

As we wait for the elections, the stock markets, which always has its own mind, is struggling.

None of us have any doubts that there is a marked slowdown in the economy. There is consensus on this, and everyone safely presumes a ride back to growth sooner rather than later. No one has any basis for prognosis and there are vague references to what is very wrongly and loosely labelled as ‘green shoots’.

On the ground, the slowdown is palpable. Talk to businessmen or a look at the job market confirms this. From automobiles to soaps, the consumer is cautious. Banks are sitting on a huge pile of problem loans and are trying their desperate best to keep it hidden from scrutiny. It is possible that if prudent norms were followed on write-offs, many banks will not have any net worth left.

However, the ‘experts’ are saying that the ‘worst’ is over. With stock markets at all time highs, is this the ‘worst’? The problem is that we do not know where we are at the present moment! High quality stocks are very expensive and the valuation of poor quality or those with dubious management or businesses are not very cheap either. So, assuming that the ‘worst’ is over for the markets, is there any significant upside left in the markets?

What growth the world is witnessing, seems to be more of productivity gains and efficiency improvements rather than growth along with more jobs.

Business can be divided in to two groups- One that is dependent mainly on government policies and spending- infrastructure, capital goods etc. After a change in government, a new government has to have strong economic policy that gives thrust to development expenditure. Given the precarious finances, whichever government comes, this looks very difficult. There is simply no money. And if someone says that public private participation will be the engine it would be very tough to visualise. With so much emphasis on transparency and public scrutiny, the enthusiasm for these kinds of projects is going to be low. We saw environmental clearances, corruption and other things holding up government policy formulation and implementation. If a third front government comes, do you think this will get any better? And if UPA or BJP manage to come to power, the problems would be higher- boycotting parliament, creating policy paralysis, uber-socialism is going to take away the revenues for populist schemes.

The second set of business (FMCG, Consumer durables, pharmaceuticals, etc) are driven by consumer spend and retail credit expansion. There could also be some impact on this by the freebies thrown at people by populist moves like NREGA etc. This sector is the one keeping economic growth in positive territory for the last few years. There is a distinct possibility that the lack of new jobs can threaten this story.

Political uncertainties have not stopped the flow of funds in to this market. So, in a sense, the surge of liquidity in to our markets has been very benevolent. In such a situation, global economic trends would tend to cast their shadow far deeper than they normally would. This is because our markets are more dependent on global money flows rather than any serious domestic investor moneys.

So, again, it is a question of wait and watch. If you are a serious investor, pray that the political uncertainty gives room to pessimism. And we also have to hope that the good quality stocks crack. The market is so finely strung that any minor disappointments from results can cause deep price swings.

It is time to keep the shopping list handy and start praying for negative impact news flow on the markets which are tightly strung now. The sectors to keep an eye out for would be limited to the consumer spending domestic group. And IT majors, if they correct seriously. I do not sense ‘investment opportunities’ any other place.

It is true that the broad indices have had a total pull back from 2008. However, the number of stocks participating has been far lower. Quality has become expensive, since 2008. The rest have become merely a trading opportunity. Thus, a long term investor has to bide his time. He could end up holding cash for long periods in time, should markets continue to be like this.

Corporate results have begun to show some tiredness. Most corporate are uncertain about the future. Even in the US, whilst the last quarter has been an exceedingly good one, the guidance on the future is not very hot. Thus, the markets are stuck in a groove. We are stuck In a trading range, for some time to come. The election results could give some push to the market. Till then, it is sensible to hang in there and use any serious rallies or pull back.

Reading the Balance Sheet- Abusing Capital


We buy shares in specific companies because we use these companies as a proxy to participate in the business they do. For example, if I am betting on Colgate, I am betting on the toothpaste business predominantly. If I buy shares in Cummins, I am betting on their being able to produce and sell diesel engines far more efficiently than many others.

Thus, I expect each company to have its capital almost fully allocated to the main business I choose it for. “Capital Allocation” by every company is a key factor for me to take a call on the company. Just to give an example, let us take L &T. It is known for its competence in engineering related skills and strength. So I would expect the company to use the resources to focus on that business. In case it generates far more cash than what can be used by the business, I would expect the company to pay higher dividends. Or it could do a share buyback. But, what does the company actually do? Let us see:

Eng &Con Elec/Elec Mchinry IT Fin Dev Proj Others Elimin Total

(Rupees crores if not mentioned otherwise)

Top Line 58616 4846 2880 4999 4080 1406 52 -1683 75196

Seg P&L 6051 547 458 1107 848 412 8 -105 9326

65% 6% 5% 12% 9% 4% 0% -1%

Seg Ass 52170 3658 2146 3218 36593 33755 196 131736

40% 3% 2% 2% 28% 26% 0% 0%

Seg Liab 29782 1540 944 870 30141 6658 21 69956

The above data is from a section called ‘segment’ reporting from the latest annual report. Essentially, this section shows how much of assets are deployed in various businesses and what revenues it derives from each. There is one level after this, where there are expenses and assets that cannot be allocated to a specific business, which comes off from the total profits etc.

I look at the above and wonder- Why are they deploying so much money in to two segments named Finance and Developmental Projects? I recall that they used to have a modest finance business to support their sale of earth moving equipments. But it now seems to be a monster, with nearly 30% of the assets attributed to that company and that contributes to less than ten percent of the bottom line, before allocations. The case with Developmental Projects seems even worse. Maybe the company executives know better. Maybe when these projects can be exited from, the company will make piles of money. Who knows?

There are innumerable such examples. For example, I think ITC share prices are depressed because they have allocated capital to poor businesses like hotels, paper, and consumer products etc which earn far less than the highly profitable cigarette business. I think that if ITC did not have the other cyclical and poor return businesses, the share price could have been a couple of times higher than what it is today. I do not buy the argument of being protective of the future. Should the cigarette business have to be shut down, it does not matter to me as a shareholder. I know the risks. If I want to be present in hotels or consumer products, I may buy shares in Indian Hotels or HUL. In fact, if we take the amount that ITC has shovelled in to FMCG business over the years, including the massive losses and put it in to shares of HUL or Gillette or Godrej Consumer Products, the returns would have been spectacular.

When management or promoters decide to wrongly allocate capital, it is a negative sign. Let us take the latest move of the Government of India to force one company to acquire shares in the other. Why should the government do this? If I wanted to, I would buy a mutual fund or an investment company share. If I buy ONGC shares, it is for the prospective return from Oil exploration etc and not by making money in the share market.

Ultimately, if we put money in to shares of companies that wrongly allocate capital based on whims of owners and managers, the returns suffer. The owner is using our money to fuel his personal whims and fancies. Whether it be buying a private jet or a helicopter or investing in totally unrelated business with poor returns, the impact is the same- lowering of returns to the shareholder.

Misallocation of capital is perhaps one of the biggest corporate governance issues. As a minority shareholder, we never get a choice to have a say in this. For example, we had to read from the newspaper that Exide (a company that one invested in because it made automotive batteries) suddenly became the owner of an insurance company! The promoter did not even bother to take shareholder approval and the independent directors must have simply nodded their heads when the investment call was taken. Or when Piramals used the cash to buy shares in Vodafone, the principle was the same. Just because a decision turns out to be subsequently profitable, does not justify the wrong.

Same is the case where the Birla Group uses one company to hold shares in another. What they are doing is essentially create holding companies which they can control, using public money. And also spoil the returns for the other shareholders.

I get worried when I see companies sitting on large cash balances. It is like money burning holes in the pocket. One day, some investment banker will come and make the promoter buy out some business where there could be personal ego fulfilment, but no shareholder returns. IT companies like Infosys or TCS are worrying due to large cash balances that are kept in bank fixed deposits. Surely they do not have to worry about finding money if they have to buy something. The share is a fantastic currency. And after Satyam, there is always a niggling worry about the existence of the cash balances.

In the not too distant past, we recall that DLF, riding high on the back of an overpriced IPO and inflated market capitalisation, had diversified in to so many businesses, claiming ‘synergies’. Now they are trying to exit most of those, claiming that they want to be ‘focused’. Again, this is a case of misallocation of capital.

Misallocation of capital is worse when there is leverage or borrowing to fulfil that desire. Only time will tell whether the buying to Corus by Tata Steel or Novellus by Hindalco is good or bad for the shareholder who is left with underperforming shares and a large debt, apart from the ‘goodwill’ (the difference between the value of assets bought and the higher price paid to buy them) that has been eaten away. Ideally, one would have thought that before such a decision, other shareholders should also have a say. And it is more relevant, because in both these cases, the non promoter stakes are substantially higher than that of the promoter.

So next time you see an annual report, try and see this interesting section called ‘segment’ reporting. It is a good indicator of how much the promoter/ professional manager cares for the other shareholders. And just to add, don’t fall in to the trap of accepting CSR as an excuse for the manager or promoter doing dumb things with money.

Sunday, February 2, 2014

BALANCED VIEW ON BALANCED FUNDS


BALANCED FUNDS Balanced funds are an interesting investment option for those who wish to avoid the hassle of direct equities, do not want too much stress and can save regularly. Balanced funds are generally not as balanced as the name indicates. For instance, if I see the portfolio of the scheme run by ICICI or HDFC, the investment is almost two thirds in equities and one third in debt instruments.

The main investment strategy for balanced funds would be to have a higher proportion in equities when equities are doing well and to reduce the proportion of equities when the equities are richly valued and not much upside is expected. However, for reasons of taxation, many mutual funds prefer or have opted for a strategy where the majority corpus is always weighted in favour of equities.

However, it is interesting to see how two large balanced funds have done over different time periods. I must say that I do not have any preference or bias for or against any fund and simply choosing them since they are popular names.

Measuring point to point returns, I get the following (annualised percentages):

6m 1yr 2yrs 3yrs 5yrs

ICICI Pru Balanced 12.2 6.3 14.2 11.0 18.9

HDFC Balanced 16.9 7.4 11.1 9.5 22.4

Sensex 6.0 3.1 9.2 3.8 16.8

With around two thirds of the money in equities, these funds have delivered far better returns than the benchmark equity index. This is simply by protecting part of the corpus in fixed income securities and by actively managing the equity allocation out of the total corpus.

These are point to point returns. Let us see how the same group has done under the SIP route, over one, three and five years:

1 year 3 years 5 years

ICICI Pru Balanced 22.7 14.8 14.1

HDFC Balanced 26.2 12.1 13.7

Kotak Sensex ETF 13.2 9.1 8.8

(returns are in annualised percentage per annum. ETF is a proxy for the BSE Sensex)

Again, the active fund managers have beaten the passive indices by a big margin even under the SIP route.

Balanced funds are generally ignored by most investors simply because most assume that it is only a matter of allocating funds between equities and debt. However, the window of flexibility in changing the allocation between the asset classes actively is what seems to have given the extra edge to balanced funds as opposed to plain equities. And one can clearly see that the returns seem to be far higher in the SIP route.

Another interesting thing is that the SIP route shows balanced funds to be at a huge advantage as opposed to the index. Typically, if we take the SIP route in equity funds as opposed to the equity indices, the difference would not be of this magnitude.

Many investors think Balanced Funds are inferior to Income funds. However, Income funds in India have not done well over the last decade, simply because of the interest rate movements that have been wild. Following were the Income fund category returns (annualised) ;

5 years- 6.64 %

3 years- 8.13%

1 year 5.24%

Thus, Income has even lagged liquid fund returns in India. Liquid funds delivered annualised returns of 7.3%; 8.88% and 8.94% over five, three and one year periods, respectively. Thus, I would totally avoid Income funds and look at Liquid funds and Balanced Funds provide excellent options in the mutual fund investment route. If I had invested through the SIP in Franklin India Bluechip Fund, I would have got annualised returns of 10.25%, 8.89% and 14.5% over 5, 3 and 1 year periods. Again, the Balanced fund options have done better.

Well one could argue that the Balanced Fund performance has been good because of smaller size relative to the good equity funds. For instance, a fund like HDFC Top 200 has a huge corpus and investing that money in to good ideas is a tough ask. And small investments, even if they have great returns, do not impact the overall scheme performance. Thus, size can become an enemy of performance. However, even in those large sizes, the SIP route has delivered better than the stock indices.

So, next time you are thinking of a SIP through the mutual fund route, I would recommend a decent allocation to the Balanced Funds.

February 1st, 2014

Thursday, January 23, 2014

The electronics and gadget shop on Ritchie Street


"Ritchie Street" in Chennai is known to every serious electronics buyer. You name it, they have it. Whether it is a simple box of CDs or a flash drive to the latest gizmo from Apple or Google or Microsoft. They are launched here well before the official launch.

One of the shopkeepers, let me call him X, is a typical operator out there- A small cramped shop, with the shelves bursting with the latest gadgets and four young lads handling clients and X sitting at the counter.X makes it a point to talk to all the regulars and pushes more sales.

I was meeting X after a couple of years. He mentioned that in the last two years, he has opened sourcing centres in Singapore and Dubai. And he has got himself a new BMW 7 series and an Audi A8. He said that he cannot bring it to the shop due to the traffic problems so he typically takes an auto to the shop and in the evening his driver picks him up. He wanted to know from me if I could help him buy a few acres of land near where I stay. The going rate is around Rs.40 cr an acre.

Obviously, this entrepreneur has done very well, selling electronics.

I recall him today, as I read this piece in the newspapers:

http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/economy/foreign-trade/mp3-player-for-rs-2-led-torch-for-rs-8-importers-undervalue-chinese-goods-make-a-killing/articleshow/29228863.cms

X is a nice person. He knows the cops, the politicians and loves to eat at new places. And his shop is wonderful. He does not mind accepting payments in cash or credit card. Asked him about taxes etc. He mentioned that his cars were bought on loan- closed in three months- but when the tax man checks his source of money, no further questions asked. And yes, he does pay some taxes. He employs a CA firm to handle his books. And pays retainer to a couple of lawyers too.

Sunday, January 19, 2014

Our Moon Has Blood Clots- A book review -


“When I saw Nehru for the first time in Lal Chowk, I was a refugee in my own state. Sixty years later, I am a refugee in my own country.”

This sentence from the book “Our Moon Has Blood Clots” gives a brutal paraphrase of the Kashmiri Pandits’ plight. Rahul Pandita, a Kashmiri Pandit lived the first fourteen years of his life in Kashmir is now a journalist and an author, living in New Delhi. There is a dearth of writing and reporting on what happens in Kashmir and no one is sure about the veracity of news that comes out of there. This book deserves to be widely read to give us a perspective on what the conflict is all about.

This book narrates the plight of the author’s personal journey from a Kashmir whose tranquillity and peace has been broken permanently by fanatics who believe in Kashmir not being a part of India. The narrative is useful to piece together the gradual movement that started with terror on the dawn of independence and has accelerated in a way that it looks impossible to halt the cry for separation. There is enough anecdotal references in the book that date to as recent as 2012, which shows the total dominance of the faith driven populace who do not wish to be labelled as Indians. Unfortunately, this vision also includes the annihilation of people who do not share the faith.

Violence and brutality has been the weapon used by those who seem to think that Kashmir is Pakistan rather than India. Right at the dawn of independence, they started by targeting everyone who did not have allegiance to Islam. Whether it was Sikh, Hindu or Christian it made no difference to those who unleashed violence of the worst kind in the name of Islam. Killing, raping and looting commenced right in 1947. After the first few years, the only Hindus left were the Kashmiri Pandits. The ethnic cleansing by the fanatics continued through and the second and final wave commenced in 1990 which saw the Kashmiri Pandits departing en masse.

The story draws on the author’s life of growing up in an environment that was certainly not friendly, but one which was tinged by a hope that ‘things will revert to normal’. The story captures the people who after being friends and neighbours with you for so long, suddenly turn around and gang up on you. I shudder to think of what the author must have gone through when the first revelation strikes him at a cricket match where the entire audience whips up Pakistani flags and cheer an Indian loss. Perhaps, that is everyday life out there.

The story also tells us about the apathy and in some cases, the complicity of the political rulers as well as the local police and administration in shooing away the ‘infidels’. It surely sets us thinking about whether there is any hope in the future of a Kashmir that will be India. With the passage of time, each incident seems to imply that our enemies across the border are leaving no stone unturned to ensure strife and militancy in Kashmir. The fact that some part of India has to be under curfew for the hanging of someone like Afzal Guru, tells us what the situation in Kashmir now. The author also captures the slow and unhurried life in Kashmir before the rot set in. It is clear that the religious divide is an imported problem.

The loss of home and homestead and then the treatment of the Kashmiri Pandits in ‘refugee’ camps is mind numbing. Here are people who stayed in the lap of nature, in houses with ten, twenty, thirty rooms and are forced in to tin sheds with no running water or sanitation. The writer talks about how even in the rehabilitation efforts, the money has been skimmed off almost entirely by the politicians. After being deprived of a home (the fanatics simply occupied their homes and some of them had the decency to get some signed documents by throwing a pittance as sale price), the Pandits are struggling with absolutely no support from the state or from any of the political bodies that talk about oppression of the Pandits in Kashmir.

It is remarkable that all this suffering and oppression has still not made him bitter or spiteful. He still exudes hope that perhaps one day he could ‘return’ to his home. The section where he describes his visit to his own home as a visitor brings out the irony of the Kashmir that has become a home to the fanatics. In a way, the book is a telling commentary on our rulers and their lack of interest in resolving this problem. A must read for all Indians.

February 11th, 2013

Tuesday, January 14, 2014

Experts choose 10 stocks -


http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/markets/stocks/stocks-in-news/ten-stocks-that-can-return-upto-50-in-2014/articleshow/28778582.cms

These are expert views -

Has 4 real estate stocks

And a few overhyped and overpriced stocks- Britannia, Cadilla, HDFC Bank-

If you ask the experts about how much money they have personally put in those stocks, one will know the truth

Yes, 50% may come back in 2014. Remaining 50%?? God help you.

You can make a small fortune this year- If you put a big one now in these stocks.

Indian Rupee and Company earnings


THE RUPEE DEPRECIATION AND EARNINGS IMPACT

(This article published in latest Moneylife) The Indian rupee should normally depreciate at around six percent per annum against the big currencies like the US Dollar, Euro etc. I am simply using the difference between the inflation in India and the inflation in those nations. Just to give a backdrop, the US $ was worth Rs.7.50 in 1970. If I took an average inflation differential of 6% annual between India and the US (naturally, India with the higher inflation figure), the dollar should mathematically have been worth around Rs.92 by end of 2013.At a 5% differential, it should have been around Rs.61. In reality, the rupee has been cushioned to a large extent by the inflow of foreign currency through foreign remittances, FII and FDI inflows etc. If we look at our foreign exchange trade, we are consistently net importers. So we are always short of foreign exchange. We have survived due to these not trade flows that have propped up the rupee. Interestingly, if I take the 2002 average rupee to dollar rate of 48.23 and apply a 3% per annum depreciation, the rupee should have been worth around Rs.66 to the dollar by end 2013. I do not say that my method is the best or the only method, but I trust this. Purchasing power does not make sense to me, when our per capita is so poor and the day to day expenses are all globally price linked thanks to open economies. Subsidies if any come through only in petrol, diesel and kerosene. And the demand for and supply of foreign exchange is the other key determinant which can impact the rates. For the rupee to be stronger, we need to have an economy where more people want the rupee as opposed to foreign currency (exports plus remittances plus FDI/FII greater than imports & other outward flows).

This slide in the rupee can be used as an additional determinant in deciding an investment strategy.

The universe of listed in India can be broken down in to:

i) Operations in India, no imports and no exports- 100% domestic;

ii) Operations in India, net regular importer – Import intensive;

iii) Operations in India, net regular exporter- Export intensive; and

iv) Global operations- net foreign exchange earner- Global earners.

Given our expectations of foreign exchange flows, if we expect rupee to weaken over the near term, it makes sense to pick up those companies that are net earners of foreign exchange and vice versa. This is not to rule out fundamental analyses, but the foreign exchange factor would be useful in our stock picking.

At the present juncture, there is not much to move the rupee except some FII flows. FDI flows would be impacted by policy changes. The forthcoming general elections and its outcome will definitely have a bearing on this. Right now, the government is trying to restrain demand for dollars by putting curbs on dollars and providing greater incentives for exports. A falling rupee should logically help exports or earners of foreign exchange. If we were to get policy decisions that facilitate FDI in a big way, then it would be best to bet on those who are net users of foreign exchange.

As a strategy, in the near term, I would bet on foreign exchange earners- IT sector stands out as one clear winner. Yes, competition would perhaps lower the dollar pricing power to some extent, but not immediately. The momentum is clearly with the companies now. On the other hand, net users of foreign exchange- whether in capital goods or in petrochemical based commodities would see some squeeze in their margins. The ability to pass on cost increases is never unlimited.

Whilst looking at a company’s annual report, there is a table that shows the earnings and outgo of foreign exchange. Here it is best to focus on trade or business related outflows and inflows. A one off capital goods imports or dividend outflow to foreign shareholders should not be looked at. Similarly, those companies that have a high amount of foreign debt, will have higher rupee outflows. There may be some companies that have global earnings and they would be better placed if they have foreign currency debt. I ignore dividend outflows because dividends are fixed in rupee terms. It does not impact the margins or pricing power in any manner.

There are companies in commodity exports. Unfortunately, many of them could be in gem and jewellery or rice exports which are really trading on the margin rather than producers. Mining companies could gain if they are exporters. My expectation for the near term would be to bet on IT, Pharma companies with large exports, some engineering companies that have consistently growing exports. There would be some positive surprises from these sectors.

This is simply an additional input for constructing your portfolio. Fundamental analyses based on earnings and Return on Equity remains the key selection criteria as far as I am concerned.